Eric Clarke and Nicola Dibben,
Music Department,
University of
Sheffield,
Sheffield S10 5BR,
UK.
Abstract
A view of categorisation in music is proposed which questions the notion of
similarity as a single, continuous dimension. According to this view,
categories are a consequence of the relatedness of events, where
relatedness is understood as a function of the dialectical relationship
between listener and musical material. The notion of relatedness by virtue
of iconic resemblance (the view of similarity and categorisation most
commonly encountered in music theory) is contrasted with, and understood
within, a model of relatedness based upon common specification (e.g. of a
musical function, genre or cultural category). This approach therefore
includes issues of social and historical context and meanings as being
vital to an understanding of similarity and categorisation in music. An
exploratory empirical study provides preliminary confirmation of this
theory and implications for further empirical investigation are considered.